The family reached their contact, transferred to a covered wagon, and made the journey to Indiana over several days. They arrived in Elkhart County in late July 1992, exhausted, traumatized, and grateful to be alive.
“We thought we’d only stay a year or two,” Ruth says. “We thought maybe after Benton forgot about us, we could go home. But years passed. The children grew. We built a new life. And Jacob was afraid that if we ever went back, Benton would find us.”
So they stayed. Joseph and Rebecca Miller raised their children, worked hard, attended church, and never spoke about Ohio or their former life.
“The guilt was terrible,” Ruth says, crying. “We’d abandoned our community, our church, our families. We’d left under false pretenses, living under false names. The Amish don’t do such things. We’re honest people. But Jacob said it was better to be alive and ashamed than righteous and dead.”
